Not resolved
1 comment

Untrustworty Review SystemSep 21, 2010wwwvrbocom20213 says:DislikesOtherPoor customer supportComments:This site has a bogus and worthless traveler review system. The systemhas no quality control measures to validate reviews.

The reviews aresubjective and manipulated by reviewers and homeowners alike. Travelersmay say anything they like about a property no matter how untrue andoutrageous. Some travelers even plant malicious negative reviews to harmhomeowners (failed attempt to blackmail a homeowner with a negativereview to extort a refund). Homeowners often game the system by gettingcustomers to plant positive reviews.

The bottom line is you cannot trustthe traveler review system, and DO NOT base your rental decision basedon traveler reviews as they are likely unreliable and invalid.Facebook User (Power Visitor)The best use of this site is Other. LikesActive communityDislikesHard to navigatePoor customer supportSite is slow and unresponsiveComments:I list 3 properties with HomeAway of my own, and at one time had about25 that I manage with them. The customer service has never been much ofanything. Their focus is on getting more & more owners, andadvertisers, but they don't seem concerned with providing us value forthe money.

Their advertising encourages vacation rentals as a bargain,bashes hotels, and now smushes the test baby. People who relate to theseare not our target market. It's mom, grandpa, and extended familiesmaking the decision. Bleck.Hard to list.

Heavy handed managment.Expensive.Canibalistic PredatorsNov 18, 2011dbo9 (Casual Visitor)The best use of this site is Other.DislikesOtherComments:Canibalistic predators - I believe from Texas - that have bought severalexisting vacation rental sites and proceeded to destroy them bymurdering everything in them that was good and usefull, replacing themwith just ways to milk their subscribers for every penny. Also idioticpolicy and system.Not focused on customersMar 03, 2012upstateny (Power Visitor)LikesEasy to navigateDislikesOtherPoor customer supportComments:I have three waterfront homes listed in upstate NY. I find the siteeasy to navigate and ok to update and I appreciate that there are a goodnumber of hits by potential guests. However the "good" ends there.Customer Service: they have NONE - people to answer the phone, but notechnology knowledge or ability to correct any bugs with the system.

Ihave had bugs open for over a year. They consistently are advertisingIN YOUR FACE additional features for additional cost before you canactually use the site. The site is expensive compared to itscompetitors. Using their payment system for rentals is very expensive.I am just waiting for competitor sites to improve their traffic and Iam gone.San Francisco, CA4/16/2008Beware!When we arrived at the property listed as #153095 on the website,for ourreserved time, the key lock box did not work.

We called the owner andhe said he didn't know who I was. When I told him I had documentationfrom him to me, then he started saying it was the wrong week. I againstated I had documentation from him to me confirming the date andshowing he had charged my credit card. Then he said the maid hadn't beenthere so the house was dirty.

We didn't take the house.The website Vacation Rentals By Owner offers the promise of 150,000 properties to rent for days, weeks or months.Most listings show pictures of the properties and traveler reviews. Boulder resident Jason Mendelson spent about $10,000 for athree-month rental of a one-bedroom house in Yountville, California, a Napa town renowned for its culinary offerings. The house had racked up several positive reviews from renters on a month and a half into the rental period, after hearing late night scratching through the walls, Mendelson’s fiancé realized that the house had been infested with rats. The owner Lupe DeLeon says rats are an unfortunate epidemic in the area (disconcerting for diners who shell out small fortunes for a meal at nearby Thomas Keller’s French Laundry).For Mendelson and his fiancé, the rat outbreak led to disputes with DeLeon over cleaning fees and reimbursement for a hotel stay.Chalking it up to a bad experience, Mendelson simply wanted to give his appraisal of the landlord and property in the same place where other renters had written their positive reviews on

Mendelson sent his comments to VRBO. But a week later, Mendelson made a surprising discovery. Instead of posting his opinion of the property, VBRO removed all reviews for DeLeon’s listing. “My ultimate issue was not with the landlord.

I thought I owed it to the VRBO community to let them know what my experience was,” says Mendelson. “I was extremely disappointed that they don’t want to have atransparent marketplace of communication about these things.” Mendelson’s initial review is now posted on his personal blog.Mendelson’s experience raises the question of what types of disclosures consumers should expect on sites that let strangers exchange goods and services. DeLeon pays $300 per year to list each of his properties on “Owners say they pay us to advertise their properties so they feel like they should have a say,” says Alexis De Belloy, a Vice President at Vacation Rentals By Owner’s parent company, Home

DeLeon agrees: “I didn’t want to give them the opportunity to just trash me,” he says. “I know I could’ve responded on the site, but I didn’t want to get into it.”VRBO’s official policy is to let owners either open up their properties to all reviews, both positive and negative, or none, says De Belloy. De Belloy says is the only one of HomeAway’s 15 websites, including three US vacation rental sites, that allows owners to opt out of reviews. On HomeAway’s other websites, he says, owners must show all reviews.

DeLeon, who lists three other properties in California and Mexico on VRBO, still shows traveler reviews on his otherproperties.VRBO did not engage in overtly deceptive advertising. Mary Engle, the associate director for advertising practices with the Federal Trade Commission, says the agency has clear rules for what constitutes deceptive advertising.The FTC, she says, might take action against a website which posted only positive reviews and dropped negative ones without making that clear to the consumer. Still she says the FTC hasn’t seen a case like this yet, and VRBO’s opt-out policy clearly doesn’t fit into that paradigm.The company’s policy does raise questions about overall transparency and consumer expectations online and on new online marketplaces, forums that are rapidly proliferating. VRBO tries to both serve potential buyers who want more insight into properties they might rent and sellers who pay the website for the service of listing their homes.

Whileconsumers wouldn’t expect other companies that sell goods online to air every consumer gripe, VRBO appears to trade on the crowdsourcing check on quality that sites like Yelp offer by posting reviews. Yet, VRBO is ultimately a forum for paid advertising. While consumers who spend enough time on the site might realize that some owners have opted out ofreviews and come to understand VRBO’s policy, it’s not explicitly clear.Social media has democratized the public airing of complaints. Anyone can post negative reviews on their personal blog and hope for an audience.

As a managing director at Boulder, Colorado venture firm The Foundry Group, Mendelson has an outsized social media presence and more ways to get the word out than the typical consumer. Other people hadsimilar experiences, as you can see from the comments’ section of his blog. Have you had a similar experience with reviews or overall transparency on other websites? Drop me a line at or leave a comment below.Sealy, TX10/12/2012From owners perspective, its a poor customer experience as well.

Whilesupport is very polite, they are entirely inadequate in taking care ofthier owner customers, almost feels like they are monopolistic in theirapproach. Wait, that is exactly the problem.I hope that the VPs are listening. its rather sad to see basic logic not prevail in a good austin based company.3/4/2011Joan C.I have used Homeaway for my vacation rental home for three years. While theweb site is easy to navigate for owners and renters alike, their customer service department is woefully inadequate.As an owner, I pay a fee each year to have my home listed.

For this fee, I expect atleast a shred of support when there's an issue with my site. Today I made the sixth phone call to customer support.

Each time, I receive the same reply: technical support is working on it, and they will call me back, or the customer service rep will call me back.Each time I've been patient, but today I lost it and today I'm Yelping!!!!Bottom line: $350+ for the listing, and no support at all. Terrible.

Product or Service Mentioned: Homeaway Property Listing.

Monetary Loss: $995.

Do You Have Something To Say ?
Write a review


Terms of Service
Post Comment
San Diego, California, United States #689778

The reviews on VRBO are fake, written by the homeowners. Our neighbor put reviews on his site for Casa Azul in San Diego that have dates when his ex-wife and her mother were still living in the house and it was not ever rented.

When they decided to rent it they put reviews that dated back over a year before they ever rented it out.

There have never been any updated reviews since 2012 when they actually started renting it out. Seems funny to me that not one person actually gets a review posted.

You May Also Like